« Unfit for Command Revisited | Main | Truth and the Beholder »

September 05, 2004

Slime and Relativity

Matt Yglesias claims that I'm "all upset" about his failure to condemn Democratic smears, and quickly assures his audience that he would not hesitate to condemn smear tactics by his side if they occur. Of course, I had no expectation of him (or anyone else) condemnning Democratic smears, particularly since in this case the smears Estrich advocates have not (yet) been made. (Other than by her, but we'll let that slide.) Indeed, the comment was intended simply as a gentle gibe, but I suppose I should consider myself fortunate I didn't draw this response.

But some of the comments left, presumably by Matt's readers (thanks for the link, buddy), made it clear that 'smear' is wholly in the eye of the beholder. According to one commenter, Estrich is calling for less than half of what the Republicans (the commenter offers up several alternate spellings for Republican, suggesting to me that his skills at rational discourse don't go far beyond 'liar, liar, pants on fire) are doing to Kerry. Now, looking at the list Stephen Bainbridge has amassed of smears the Democrats have already engaged in, that seems hard for me to believe. But, my sympathies do tend to lie closer to the Republicans than the Democrats, so it's certainly possible I'm not seeing things clearly. Presumably those coming from the left would point to those as perfectly acceptable campaign tactics, and not all out-of-line. And I'm not sure of any way to objectively disagree.

Well, it doesn't really matter as far as I'm concerned. The campaigns are going to do what they think is effective (although I think Kerry had best come up with a better counterattack than 'they're attacking my patriotism,' a claim that is objectively untrue). All we can do as voters is determine what matters most to us in a president and vote accordingly.

I'll be glad when November 3d gets here, though.

Posted at September 5, 2004 03:04 PM

Andrew Olmsted

Trackback Pings

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://andrewolmsted.com/cgi-bin/MoveableType/mt-tb.cgi/821

Comments

you fascists make me sick! you reugs are nazis with your nationalistic miltitaristic rallys like numemberg and howy ou crush dissent of your far right agenda. i hope kerry wins and yuo far right 'warbloogers' are locked up for slander!

Posted by: Bush Still Lied!!! at September 5, 2004 04:34 PM

that first comment would be funny if it weren't so nasty. So much for the first amendment rights of anyone who is a republican. Apparently, the writer doesn't remember the troubles sedition laws caused our second president, John Adams.

I will also be glad to see the end of this campaign in Nov. The only problem is that we know that the 2008 campaign will start on the day after the election no matter who wins. On some tv shows, it has already begun.

Posted by: Dad at September 6, 2004 09:14 AM

It's interesting to me to see how the Democrat rationalizations of beyond-the-pale domestic political behavior (baseless slander, comparisons of those who disagree with them to mass murderers (but not, curiously, Communist mass murderers, whom they still seem to support), outright lying about what their opponents have done and said even at risk to national security) lines up with the rationalizations of beyond-the-pale terrorist attacks like Beslan from "moderate" imams.

I really don't understand this kind of reflexive partisan defense: calling out your loonies makes good political sense (defusing your opponents' attacks on things you really can't defend anyway) as well as being the morally right approach. Unless, of course, people like Matt actually agree with such destructive campaign tactics.

Posted by: Jeff Medcalf at September 6, 2004 09:36 AM

Reugs, Repugs, Rethugs. Those on the left typically feel the need to resort to name-calling especially since all those of us on the right need to do is identify them as "liberals" and they scurry for cover. They hate that their own label has become an object of scorn, and so they resort to such silly ad hominems in a pathetic attempt to even the score. But that will never happen as it wasn't conservatives who made the appellation "liberal" an object of derision, it was the leftists themselves.

Posted by: MartiniPundit at September 9, 2004 02:35 PM

Post a comment




Remember Me?

(you may use HTML tags for style)